1.0 Introduction
1.1 Background of Study
Historically, Baptist churches have adhered to a theology centered on salvation through faith, the authority of Scripture, and the importance of stewardship and humility (McBeth, 1987). However, the growing influence of prosperity preaching introduced shifts in theological discourse, particularly in urban and charismatic Baptist congregations. Some Baptist churches began to integrate aspects of prosperity teachings into their sermons, emphasizing financial breakthroughs, divine healing, and material success as rewards for faith and generous giving (Coleman, 2020).
The impact of prosperity preaching on Baptist churches has been both transformative and controversial. While some argue that it has encouraged financial empowerment and generosity among believers, others contend that it has led to a commercialization of faith, where monetary contributions are often linked to expectations of personal gain (Gifford, 2015). Prosperity preaching, also referred to as the prosperity gospel or the Word of Faith movement, is a theological trend that asserts that faith, positive confession, and financial giving to religious causes will result in divine blessings, including wealth and health (Bowler, 2013). The rise of prosperity preaching can be traced back to mid-20th-century televangelism, with its roots in American Pentecostalism and the healing revival movements (Gifford, 2015). Over time, its influence has extended across denominational boundaries, including into traditionally conservative Baptist churches.
Baptist churches have historically emphasized salvation through faith, scriptural authority, and personal holiness, distinguishing themselves from movements that prioritize material wealth as a sign of divine favor (McBeth, 1987). However, the growing prominence of Neo-Pentecostal prosperity teachings has introduced theological tensions within Baptist congregations, leading to shifts in doctrine, worship practices, and members’ expectations regarding financial and spiritual success (Coleman, 2020).
Prosperity preaching, also known as the prosperity gospel or the Word of Faith movement according to Bowler (2013), is a religious belief that financial blessing and physical well-being are divine rights of Christians, attained through faith, positive speech, and donations to religious causes (Bowler, 2013). Baptist churches, traditionally rooted in evangelical and doctrinal conservatism, have historically emphasized salvation through faith in Jesus Christ, scriptural authority, and moral discipline (McBeth, 1987). However, the growing influence of Neo-Pentecostal prosperity preaching has introduced shifts in theological perspectives, worship practices, and church administration within Baptist congregations.
Coleman (2020) stated that, the impact of prosperity preaching on Baptist churches raises significant theological and practical concerns. While some argue that it fosters financial generosity and faith-driven success, critics contend that it distorts biblical teachings, prioritizes material wealth over spiritual growth, and undermines the core principles of Baptist doctrine (Coleman, 2020). The adoption of prosperity preaching within Baptist churches has sparked debates among theologians and church leaders. While some proponents argue that it fosters faith-driven financial responsibility and generosity, critics assert that it distorts biblical teachings, encouraging materialism and weakening the traditional Baptist emphasis on humility and stewardship (Asamoah-Gyadu, 2005). Therefore, this study explores the impact of Neo-Pentecostal prosperity preaching on Baptist churches by examining its theological implications, its influence on church governance and congregational expectations, and the broader consequences for Baptist traditions and values.
1.2 Statement of Problems
Investigation revealed that the influence of prosperity preaching is also affecting the expectations of congregants. Many church members are beginning to view financial prosperity as a measure of faith, leading to disappointment and disillusionment when expected material blessings do not materialize (Asamoah-Gyadu, 2005).
Additionally, the emphasis on prosperity is shifting the focus of Baptist missions and social outreach. Rather than prioritizing traditional efforts such as evangelism, education, and community service, some churches are increasingly directing resources toward prosperity-driven programs, which is raising concerns about the long-term impact on Baptist identity and its role in society (Ukah, 2021).
Furthermore, some Baptist pastors are adopting prosperity messages to attract larger congregations and increase financial contributions, sometimes at the expense of biblical integrity (Coleman, 2020). Therefore, this research study seeks to explore how prosperity teachings are influencing Baptist beliefs, worship practices, church leadership, and congregational expectations.
1.3 Aim and Objectives of Study
The aim of this study is to examine the impact of Neo-Pentecostal prosperity preaching on Baptist churches. The objectives of this study include:
- To analyze the theological differences between traditional Baptist teachings and Neo-Pentecostal prosperity preaching.
- To examine how prosperity preaching is affecting the doctrinal integrity of Baptist churches.
- To assess the influence of prosperity teachings on pastoral leadership and church governance in Baptist congregations.
- To investigate how prosperity preaching is shaping the financial expectations and spiritual commitments of Baptist church members.
- To evaluate the effects of prosperity messages on the missions, outreach, and social responsibilities of Baptist churches.
1.4 Research Questions
This study seeks to answer the following research questions based on the stated objectives:
- What are the theological differences between traditional Baptist teachings and Neo-Pentecostal prosperity preaching?
- How is prosperity preaching affecting the doctrinal integrity of Baptist churches?
- In what ways is prosperity preaching influencing pastoral leadership and church governance in Baptist congregations?
- How is prosperity preaching shaping the financial expectations and spiritual commitments of Baptist church members?
- What impact is prosperity preaching having on the missions, outreach, and social responsibilities of Baptist churches?
- What measures can be taken to maintain theological balance and doctrinal purity within Baptist churches while addressing the challenges posed by prosperity preaching?
1.5 Significance of Study
The outcome of this research will help clarify how prosperity preaching may impact their spiritual practices, financial expectations, and overall faith journey. For theologians and scholars, this study will contribute to the academic discourse on the intersection of Neo-Pentecostalism and traditional Christian denominations.
Additionally, this study will reveal the impact of prosperity preaching on the financial expectations and spiritual commitments of Baptist church members.
Furthermore, the study will provide a critical perspective on how the focus on prosperity will influence the missions, outreach, and social responsibilities of Baptist churches. As churches adapt to prosperity-driven messages, this research will evaluate the broader effects on their role in society and their commitment to traditional Baptist values such as evangelism and community service.
1.7 Scope of Study
This study will focus on the impact of Neo-Pentecostal prosperity preaching on Baptist churches in Lagos State, Nigeria. The scope will cover Baptist churches that have integrated aspects of prosperity preaching into their teachings and practices, as well as those that have resisted these influences.
1.8 Limitations of the Study
The study was limited by time and resource constraints, restricting the number of churches that could be surveyed. As a result, the research was based on a sample from various districts within Lagos, which might not have fully represented the diversity of Baptist congregations across the state.
Additionally, the study relied on the perceptions of church leaders, members, and existing church literature. This was a limitation, as it could have introduced biases or subjectivity into the findings, particularly when discussing sensitive topics such as financial giving and doctrinal differences.
Finally, due to the sensitive nature of financial contributions and doctrinal debates, some church leaders or members were reluctant to openly share their experiences or opinions regarding prosperity preaching.
1.9 Definition of Terms
Neo-Pentecostalism:
Neo-Pentecostalism refers to a modern, charismatic Christian movement that emerged in the late 20th century, characterized by an emphasis on the power of the Holy Spirit, speaking in tongues, healing, and miraculous signs. Neo-Pentecostals often blend traditional Pentecostal beliefs with newer theological emphases, including prosperity teachings (Maxwell, 2006). The movement is known for its charismatic worship style and often integrates elements of popular culture in its ministry practices.
Prosperity Preaching:
Prosperity preaching, also known as the "prosperity gospel" or "word of faith" theology, is a belief system within some segments of Christianity that teaches financial success, physical health, and personal well-being are rewards for faith and positive confession (Higgins, 2004). The central tenet is that faith, positive declarations, and tithing to the church will lead to prosperity.
Baptist Churches:
Baptist churches are a denomination of Protestant Christianity known for their belief in adult baptism by full immersion and a strong emphasis on the autonomy of the local church. Baptists generally hold conservative theological views, prioritizing the authority of Scripture and the necessity of personal conversion (Graham, 2008).
Theological Impact:
Theological impact refers to the effect that a particular set of beliefs or teachings has on the core doctrines and faith practices of a religious group. in the context of this study, the theological impact concerns how Neo-Pentecostal prosperity preaching influences the doctrinal positions, biblical interpretations, and overall belief system of Baptist churches (Tennent, 2010).
Doctrinal Integrity:
Doctrinal integrity refers to the adherence to and preservation of core religious beliefs that define a particular faith tradition. For Baptist churches, doctrinal integrity involves maintaining fidelity to traditional teachings and practices as outlined in Baptist confessions of faith and historical theological positions. The introduction of prosperity preaching may challenge this integrity by promoting teachings that are seen as divergent from the core tenets of Baptist doctrine (Nelson, 2007).
…
