1.0 Introduction
1.1 Background of Study
The relationship between Nigeria and Cameroon from 1990 to 2007 was marked by both cooperation and tension, primarily due to the historical and political issues surrounding territorial disputes, economic engagements, and regional security concerns. The period under review was significant as it involved key developments that shaped the diplomatic landscape of the two nations and the broader Central and West African regions. A central issue in Nigeria-Cameroon relations during this period was the longstanding dispute over the Bakassi Peninsula. This territorial conflict had its roots in colonial-era demarcations and the unclear boundaries left by the European powers. The Bakassi dispute became particularly acute in the 1990s, as both nations laid claim to the area, which was strategically important due to its proximity to the Gulf of Guinea and potential oil reserves. The dispute escalated into armed confrontations, but by 2002, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) ruled in favor of Cameroon, awarding them sovereignty over the disputed area, although the process of implementation and the reactions of both governments added complexity to the situation (Fayemi, 2007). In addition to the territorial dispute, the economic relations between Nigeria and Cameroon were essential to their bilateral ties. As two of the most significant nations in their respective regions, Nigeria, with its vast oil reserves, and Cameroon, with its agricultural exports, had opportunities for mutually beneficial trade. However, political differences often hindered the full potential of these economic relationships (Obi, 2001). Despite this, efforts to improve trade and regional integration were part of the broader aim to strengthen economic cooperation between the two countries.
According to Adibe (2005), regional security concerns, particularly regarding insurgency, terrorism, and refugee management, shaped the diplomatic relations between the two nations. Nigeria and Cameroon were both affected by the broader security challenges of the Central and West African regions, including cross-border insurgencies and the movement of refugees due to conflicts in neighboring countries. As regional powers, both nations played pivotal roles in addressing these security threats, including joint efforts in the fight against terrorism (Adibe, 2005).
The most notable issue that influenced Nigeria-Cameroon relations during this period was the Bakassi Peninsula dispute, which was rooted in conflicting territorial claims over the area. This dispute had historical, political, and economic implications, with both nations asserting their sovereignty over the region due to its strategic location and potential oil reserves (Fayemi, 2007). The conflict over Bakassi reached its peak in the 1990s and was eventually resolved by the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in 2002, when the court ruled in favor of Cameroon, although the implementation of the decision was contentious and led to further diplomatic friction. Therefore, in Nigeria where the research was carried out, the activities that was conducted is to analyze the evolving relationship between Nigeria and Cameroon from 1990 to 2007, examining the key issues, events, and diplomatic strategies that shaped their interactions.
1.2 Statement of Problems
Investigation revealed that despite numerous attempts at negotiation through regional organizations such as the Organization of African Unity (OAU) and international bodies like the United Nations, the lack of effective communication and compromise contributed to the escalation of the dispute.
Furthermore, the instability caused by this territorial dispute was compounded by the security challenges both countries faced within the broader Central African region. Cross-border insurgencies, refugee flows, and terrorism from neighboring nations such as Chad and the Central African Republic added a layer of complexity to Nigeria-Cameroon relations.
Additionally, the issue of local populations in the disputed territories, particularly in Bakassi, is also an unresolved problem. The residents, often of Nigerian origin, faced forced displacement and a loss of livelihood as a result of the changing sovereignty. The reluctance of local communities to accept the ruling of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) and the subsequent transfer of the region to Cameroon is a key challenge in ensuring long-term peace and stability. Hence, the undertaking of this research work will fill in the gap by critically analyzing the evolving relationship between Nigeria and Cameroon from 1990 to 2007.
1.3 Aim and Objectives of Study
The aim of this study is to provide a comprehensive analysis of Nigeria-Cameroon relations between 1990 and 2007, with a particular focus on the geopolitical, economic, and diplomatic challenges that defined the bilateral ties during this period. The objectives of the study are as follows:
- To examine the historical background of the territorial dispute between Nigeria and Cameroon over the Bakassi Peninsula and its implications for their bilateral relations.
- To analyze the diplomatic efforts undertaken by both countries, as well as regional and international organizations, to resolve the territorial conflict during this period.
- To assess the economic and political factors influencing Nigeria-Cameroon relations, particularly in relation to the Bakassi Peninsula's natural resources.
- To investigate the role of international bodies, such as the United Nations and the International Court of Justice, in the resolution of the dispute and its impact on bilateral relations.
- To evaluate the security implications of the dispute, including its effect on the regional stability of Central Africa and the security dynamics in both Nigeria and Cameroon.
- To explore the social and humanitarian consequences for the populations residing in the disputed territories, particularly in relation to displacement and livelihood challenges.
1.4 Research Questions
The following research questions guide the study of Nigeria-Cameroon relations from 1990 to 2007, based on the stated objectives:
- What were the historical factors that contributed to the territorial dispute between Nigeria and Cameroon over the Bakassi Peninsula, and how did this shape their bilateral relations during the period from 1990 to 2007?
- What diplomatic efforts were undertaken by both Nigeria and Cameroon to resolve the Bakassi dispute, and what role did international organizations play in these efforts?
- How did economic and political factors, particularly those related to the natural resources in the Bakassi Peninsula, influence the relations between Nigeria and Cameroon during this period?
- What role did international bodies, such as the United Nations and the International Court of Justice, play in resolving the territorial conflict between Nigeria and Cameroon, and what impact did their involvement have on bilateral relations?
- How did the territorial dispute between Nigeria and Cameroon affect the regional security dynamics in Central Africa and the internal security situations of both countries?
- What were the social and humanitarian consequences for the populations living in the disputed territories, particularly regarding displacement, livelihoods, and social integration during the period under study?
1.5 Significance of Study
The findings of this research will provide valuable insights into the role of international legal frameworks, such as the International Court of Justice (ICJ), in resolving border disputes, particularly the Bakassi Peninsula issue. This research will also contribute to the broader field of international relations by examining how bilateral negotiations and regional cooperation can influence the resolution of territorial conflicts.
Furthermore, policymakers and diplomats will benefit from the findings, as it will help in formulating strategies for peaceful conflict resolution and international collaboration in future disputes.
Additionally, scholars of African politics and international law will find the study's exploration of the historical, political, and economic factors influencing Nigeria-Cameroon relations valuable for further academic inquiry.
Lastly, the study will serve as a critical resource for researchers and institutions focused on African regional security and diplomatic relations.
1.6 Scope of Study
The scope of the research is focused on the political, economic, and diplomatic relations between Nigeria and Cameroon from 1990 to 2007, particularly in the context of border disputes, including the Bakassi Peninsula conflict.
1.7 Limitations of the Study
The study was constrained by the limited number of interviews with key stakeholders, including diplomats, government officials, and military personnel, who may have had direct involvement in the Nigeria-Cameroon relations during the period under review.
Additionally, the study was impacted by frequent power outages and inadequate technological infrastructure, which hindered the access to online resources and archival materials. The financial and time constraints of the research process also limited the scope of data collection, especially in relation to fieldwork in both countries.
Furthermore, the lack of published works and research studies focused specifically on the Nigeria-Cameroon relations during this period was a significant challenge, as it restricted the depth of the analysis and reliance on secondary sources.
Lastly, political sensitivities surrounding the border dispute, particularly concerning the Bakassi Peninsula, may have affected the willingness of some respondents to openly discuss certain issues related to the diplomatic negotiations and military interventions, thus limiting the comprehensiveness of the findings.
1.8 Definition of Terms
Nigeria-Cameroon Relations: Refers to the diplomatic, political, economic, and social interactions between the governments and peoples of Nigeria and Cameroon from 1990 to 2007. This period covers various bilateral agreements, conflicts, and cooperation, notably centered around territorial disputes, particularly the Bakassi Peninsula. These relations have evolved through both challenges and cooperation, including peace talks and economic exchanges (Adebajo, 2007).
Territorial Dispute: A disagreement between countries or regions over the possession of land. In the case of Nigeria and Cameroon, one of the key territorial disputes during the period studied was over the Bakassi Peninsula. This dispute was resolved in part by the International Court of Justice (ICJ) ruling in 2002, which granted the territory to Cameroon, though it sparked political tension in both countries (Gervais, 2006).
Bilateral Relations: Refers to the interactions and agreements between two countries. Bilateral relations can encompass areas such as trade, defense, cultural exchange, and diplomacy. In this context, the study examines the cooperative and conflictual aspects of Nigeria's and Cameroon's bilateral relations, especially in the political and economic realms (Ngwa, 2007).
Diplomacy: The practice of managing international relations through negotiation, dialogue, and peaceful communication between countries. In the study of Nigeria-Cameroon relations, diplomacy played a crucial role in resolving conflicts, such as the dispute over the Bakassi Peninsula, and in fostering economic collaboration (Wheeler, 2005).
International Court of Justice (ICJ): The primary judicial body of the United Nations, responsible for settling legal disputes between states according to international law. In the case of Nigeria and Cameroon, the ICJ ruled on the Bakassi Peninsula dispute, which became a landmark decision in the resolution of territorial disputes in Africa (Mabera, 2005).
Peacekeeping: Refers to the efforts, often led by international organizations like the United Nations, to maintain peace in conflict areas. The UN played a role in the peace process between Nigeria and Cameroon, especially in the aftermath of the ICJ ruling on the Bakassi dispute, to ensure stability in the region (Akindele, 2005).
Economic Cooperation: Refers to the partnership between two or more nations aimed at enhancing mutual economic interests. The Nigeria-Cameroon relations saw moments of economic cooperation, particularly in trade and resource management, but were often marred by the ongoing territorial disputes that affected economic ties (Kassa, 2006).
Diplomatic Negotiations: The formal discussions between governments or their representatives to resolve disputes or enhance cooperation. In the Nigeria-Cameroon case, diplomatic negotiations were integral in addressing the territorial dispute, especially through the mediation efforts of international bodies like the UN and the ICJ (Smith, 2006).
…
